As scores are entered by evaluators you may observe orange highlighting around certain criteria when you are viewing the Scoring Summary. This indicates that there is a Lack of Consensus on scoring for that particular Criteria. In Bonfire, the Lack of Consensus highlighting occurs when there is a 30% or greater spread between the lowest and highest score for a given criterion.
Let's take a look at an example:
In the example above there is a Lack of Consensus for the vendor "Days Inn" amongst its reviewers for the criteria titled "History of similar projects" and also for the "Meeting room selection". In other words, there is spread (30% or greater) between the lowest score and the highest score submitted for these two criteria. The vendor "Holiday Inn" shows a Lack of Consensus for the criteria "Range of activities".
Let's click on "Days Inn" to open up a more detailed breakdown:
In the example above we are looking at the scores from the Days Inn's Evaluation Group 1. Notice the orange highlighting the criteria with a Lack of Consensus.
For this particular criteria Renate has provided a low score of 6, meanwhile, Corry has provided a high score of 9 (indicated by the red arrows). The difference between the low and high score is 3 points. The criteria for "History of similar projects" is scored out of 10. This 3 point spread meets the threshold of 30% which triggers the Consensus highlighting to bring it to your attention.